American College of Physicians: Internal Medicine — Doctors for Adults ®


How to sell your medical degree in the job market

From the March 2001 ACP-ASIM Observer, copyright 2001 by the American College of Physicians-American Society of Internal Medicine.

by Phyllis Maguire

Just how far will your medical degree get you in the business world? Not far, analysts say, if your education is not coupled with experience.

Seth Garber, MD, a senior consultant with William M. Mercer Inc. in Seattle, often hears from physicians who want to become consultants. Some of them have both MDs and MBAs, he said. The only problem is that they've never practiced medicine and they've never worked in the business world.

"They tell me, 'By virtue of these degrees, I think I'm terrific,' " Dr. Garber said. "I say, 'By virtue of your experience, you have no credibility at all.' "

Physicians who want to leave clinical practice often look first to hospitals or health care systems for an executive administrative position. Physicians with only clinical experience might be considered for work in a single-hospital system, said Jennifer R. Grebenschikoff, vice president of the Physician Executive Management Center in Tampa, Fla., but only if they can point to strong leadership experience. Examples include tenure on a credentials committee or voluntarily heading up a local independent practice association.

"If someone comes to me with 20 years of experience as a practitioner but hasn't really done anything in leadership, there's not much I can do," Ms. Grebenschikoff said.

Gigi Hirsch, MD, founder and chief executive officer of MD IntelliNet LLC, a physician consulting and placement company, said that any experience physicians can get beyond the bedside is useful when seeking another career. Physicians who want to enter the pharmaceutical or biotech industries, for instance, should get as much clinical research experience as they can while still in practice. And physicians considering other careers need to spend as much time as possible networking with professionals and executives from other fields.

That's particularly true for physicians over the age of 50, who fall victim to the same hiring biases as the rest of the workforce. Senior physicians find it hard to land entry-level positions in other industries, even with an MBA, Dr. Hirsch said. In a few cases, she has been able to arrange unpaid industry apprenticeships as a way for physicians to get a foot in the door.

And if you are thinking of joining the thriving health care finance industry to take advantage of big stock gains and killer bonuses, be prepared to start over.

"It is appropriate to presume that you would be taking a demotion in seniority, autonomy and compensation to enter the financial community," said Wade H. King, MD, a senior medical technology research analyst for Robertson Stephens, an investment bank in San Francisco. A practicing anesthesiologist for 10 years, Dr. King spent five of those years advising venture capital groups part time about medical technology companies. He also attended Stanford Business School before joining Robertson Stephens in 1996, when he was 39 years old.

Starting over in an entry-level job is necessary, he added, because clinical experience doesn't translate to financial expertise. While his years of practice give him insight into the medical value and relevance of products, he said that the skills he uses as an analyst are different from those in play in medical practice.

"Both skill sets have a similar analytical shell," he said, but finance requires analysts to be able to evaluate management and business plans, as well as "sell" investment ideas to your own sales force. None of those skills, Dr. King said, were part of his medical training or experience.

And if you're troubled by the growing emphasis on productivity in medicine, the financial industry is not the place for you. "You're compensated and promoted based on business delivered in a tangible way that's followed quantitatively," Dr. King said. "You get paid according to how much business you bring through the door."


This is a printer-friendly version of this page

Print this page  |  Close the preview




Internist Archives Quick Links

Prescribe Opioids Safely

Prescribe Opioids Safely

Access this FREE online educational program to help you safely prescribe opioids and manage patients with chronic pain. Online CME is available. Find out more.

Inspire the Next Generation of Medicine

Inspire the Next Generation of Medicine

Contribute to the ACP Education Fund and support our profession and the young minds starting their careers.

Share your love of medicine by making a charitable donation today! All donations are tax-deductible.